New York bagels are world-famous; and it’s not just a New York City thing. Fresh from the bakery, warm, moist, and perfectly chewy, nothing quite compares to an authentic New York bagel.
Across the greater NYC metro area, there’s a long tradition of producing some of the best bagels in the world, and the Tuxedo Park area is no exception. Whether you’re a weekend visitor, a new resident, or a long-time local, these nearby bagel shops serve up classic New York flavor close to home.
Below, we’ve rounded up a few top-rated bagel shops near Tuxedo Park, NY, with full address and contact info; listed by proximity, not in order of “best.”
Jessie’s Bagels – Sloatsburg, NY
A true local institution, Jessie’s Bagels has been serving the Tuxedo Park & Sloatsburg region for years. They bake fresh every morning, offering a wide variety of bagel flavors made the traditional New York way — crisp on the outside, soft and fluffy inside. Meet their newest location, set in a converted auto-repair garage, offering a welcoming dine-in space with a cozy, casual vibe. True to their tagline, “From Bagels to Burgers,” Jessie’s serves not just bagels but also soups, sandwiches and burgers for breakfast or lunch.
Customer Tip: Grab a half-dozen bagels to take home — freeze some for later. Try the toasted whole wheat everything bagel with scallion cream cheese — it’s a local favorite!
Address: 207 Orange Turnpike (or 203 Orange Turnpike), Sloatsburg, NY 10974
Phone: (845) 753-8019
Bagel Train – Suffern, NY
One of the most popular bagel shops in Rockland County, Bagel Train often has a line out the door — a true sign of quality. Their bagels are everything you’d expect from a true New York bagel: fresh, fluffy, and full of flavor. This is a no-frills, take-out only shop, but the bagel sandwiches are legendary. From classic bacon, egg & cheese to creative deli combos, the possibilities are endless.
Customer Tip: Visit during off-hours if you want to avoid the morning rush. When it’s your turn, be ready to order — the team is friendly but fast-paced!
Address: 150 Orange Ave, Suffern, NY 10901
Phone: (845) 368-4234
Bagel Boys – Airmont (Suffern area), NY
If you’re looking for variety, Bagel Boys is a must-visit. Known for their creative twists on traditional bagels, they even offer colored bagels for holidays (think bright green for St. Patrick’s Day). You’ll also find flagels — the famous flattened bagels that toast up perfectly. Their large dine-in area makes it an ideal breakfast or lunch spot. Beyond bagels, they serve salads, soups, smoked fish and house-made spreads. Visit their website here.
Customer Tip: Try their vegetable or scallion cream cheese, or grab a container to take home.
Address: 7 N Airmont Rd, Suffern, NY 10901
Phone: (845) 368-3456
Local’s Bagel Tips
After years of enjoying local New York bagels, here are a few pro tips:
- Buy by the dozen: Most shops give a baker’s dozen (13 bagels) when you order 12.
- Freeze for freshness: Slice your bagels before freezing. When ready to eat, toast them straight from the freezer — they’ll taste almost as good as fresh.
- Try these favorite combos:
- Egg & cheese on a toasted whole-wheat everything bagel
- Tuna melt on a sesame bagel
- BLT on pumpernickel or rye bagel
We highly recommend visiting these great bagel shops near Tuxedo Park — and if you do, tell them Jake sent you!
